Critique paper on a philosophy article

(A) The critique option: In this option, you must write a critique of a specific article from the list below. A critique is a summary plus critical assessment. Keep in mind that in a critique you don’t have to disagree with the article. You can raise an objection, but you can then (if appropriate) answer it.Tips for writing a critique are given below, as is a list of articles.

Format: Use Times New Roman 14pt., doublespaced

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Critique paper on a philosophy article
Get a plagiarism free paper Just from $13/Page
Order Essay

Outside reading and integrity: This assignment can be done well without outside reading. Some of you, however, may find additional readings helpful; if so, feel free to read. In addition, you may discuss the questions with other students and with your two-year old nephew whom his parents have pegged as the next Einstein. No one else! If you do read any outside sources—print, web, or whatever– or discuss the paper with anyone you’re allowed to discuss it with, you must list those sources and discussion at the end of the paper even if you did not need to cite them in the body of the paper. If you use an idea derived from a source or a person, insert a footnote or parenthesis on the spot saying “This point was made to me by …” or some variant of that. Under no circumstances may you look for ideas and formulations used in papers by other students, past or present, even future (I like to cover all bases), here or anywhere else, about these questions. Note university policy: plagiarism and cheating will not be tolerated under any circumstances.

Grading criteria: Papers that involve a question on a reading (which is all of them) will be graded on the basis of (1) clarity (2) accuracy in presenting an author’s argument (3) argumentation and insight. (Bad grammar and weak word choice interfere with clarity). Be wary of the difference between assertion and argument. Don’t merely state your view; argue for it. Essays will be graded on a scale of 0-100. I sent rubrics before paper #1 and will resend. More on critiques below.


Tips for critiques: A good critique is a clear, rigorous, and judicious summary of an article plus insightful comments that add value to the discussion, whether by way of criticism or by way of introducing additional considerations. You may mix summary and your own comments, or do them separately. A good way to work is to (1) first identify and formulate the author’s conclusion, then (2) go back and figure out the argument (premises, inferences from one or more steps to another), then (3) evaluate the argument—e. g., are there false or questionable premises or flawed or questionable inferences. If you see a problem with the argument as stated, is the argument simply a failure, or can you make the argument better? Keep your eye on the ball—don’t spend an inordinate time on summarizing or criticizing tangential points (there are very few of those anyway); show that you understand the big picture and the main arguments. Do not comment on whether the article is well-written or well-organized. Deal with the substance. If the author is ambiguous in certain of his or her formulations, you can bring out the ambiguity.

One way to get your mind going is this: Suppose you had to conduct a class on the topic, having been assigned that particular reading. How would you present the content of the article? What questions would you raise for discussion? What questions are likely to be asked? This will get you started. You can either summarize first and then evaluate, or mix summary and evaluation as you go along (just as you can structure a class either of these ways).

Here are a few more tips for writing papers, along with answers to frequently asked questions. (1) Clarity, clarity, clarity. (2) Argue, don’t just assert. (3) Always be alert to how someone might criticize your arguments. (4) Don’t write a long intro explaining that people have been discussing this topic since time immemorial . Just get into the issue. (5) Poor grammar interferes with clarity. (6) Yes, you may absolutely use the word “I.” (7) It is up to you whether to begin with a thesis statement. In fact, you may wish to explain different perspectives on the question and not commit to one. Or, you may prefer to set out the problem your assignment deals with and hold the reader (well, I guess there’ll be only one– me) in suspense until the end. Or, the paper may lend itself to a thesis statement at the beginning (e, g,, “I will argue that Smith overlooks a key facet of the issue…” . If you do have a thesis, state it clearly atsome point.


Write a critique of a specific article. A critique, as you know by now, is a summary plus critical assessment. Write a critique of one of the following (A1-A9). Keep in mind[to repeat] that in a critique you don’t have to ultimately disagree with the article. You can raise an objection, but you can (if appropriate) then answer it.

Master Homework
Order Now And Get A 20% Discount!
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Advantages of using our writing services

Custom Writing From Scratch

All our custom papers are written by qualified writers according to your instructions, thus evading any case of plagiarism. Our team consists of native writers from the USA, Canada, and the Uk, making it convenient for us to find the best to handle your order.

Unlimited Free Revisions

If you feel your paper didn't meet all your requirements, we won't stop till it's perfect. You're entitled to request a free revision within 7 days after we submit your paper.

Quality Writing In Any Format

If you have issues with citing sources and referencing, you need not worry. Our writers are highly knowledgeable in referencing, including APA/MLA/Havard/Chicago/Turabian and all other formatting styles.

Fast Delivery And Adherence To The Deadline

All our custom papers are delivered on time, even the most urgent. If we need more time to perfect your paper, we may contact you via email or phone regarding the deadline extension.

Originality & Security

At Master Homework, your security and privacy is our greatest concern. For this reason, we never share your personal information with third parties. We use several writing tools to ensure your paper is original and free from plagiarism.

24/7 Customer Support

Our agents are online 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and are always ready to serve you. Feel free to contact us through email or talk to our live agents whenever you need assistance with your order.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

We work nonstop to see the best client experience.


Flexible Pricing

We offer pocket-friendly prices that coincide with the preferred client's deadline.


Admission help & Client-Writer Contact

Our support team is always ready to ensure vital interaction between you and the writer whenever you need to elaborate on something.


Paper Submission

We deliver our papers early within the stipulated deadlines. We are glad to help you if there should be an occurrence of any alterations required.


Customer Feedback

Your review, positive or negative, is of great concern to us and we take it very seriously. We are, consequently adjusting our policies to ensure the best customer/writer experience.